decriminalize prostitution with refrence to Devlin and Mill
- This is a preview of the essay.
To view the full text you must login!
To what extent should a moral code shape our laws? John Stuart Mill had thought that the law should only be used to ensure that citizens are protected from the harms others would inflict upon them. Self inflicted harms and moral wrongs that do not harm any individuals should not be matters that the law should deal with. Whereas Patrick Devlin believes that using the law to enforce morality is not unjust. Both parties display opposite opinions of the law, and how the law should administer our lives. When taking into consideration an issue like prostitution; a victim-less-crime, Mill proposes stronger more efficient arguments than Devlin. If certain behaviour is considered morally wrong, that alone is not enough for the creation of a criminal offence, as well as victim-less-crimes are not proper grounds to sanction people for things that merely only harm themselves. Due to time constraints and length restrictions this is a brief synopsis as to why prostitution should be legalized.
Devlin was a legal moralist, he believed in a strong moral code, and he insisted that law should be used to prohibit behaviour that conflicts with dominate morality. Devlin sought to seek a contemporary society , which in a city-state is problematic due to different interpretations and opinions...